Eh Vad Da Dei? – The Great Vadai Taste Off – Gina’s, The Original Vadai and Mr Vadai

Gina’s Vadai

For me, Gina was the OG (Original Gangster) of Vadais.

I ate Gina’s Vadai growing up and they were at a corner Coffeeshop along East Coast Road across the street from Jago Close and next to an Esso Station.

Their first location, however, was opened in 1987 in Geylang Bahru. Hence, they are sometimes known to some people as Geylang Bahru Vadai but I have always known them as Gina’s.

Gina’s now boast a glitzy website and it is currently housed at the basement of Duman Food Centre which is just behind Joo Chiat.

The Original Vadai

Johorkaki

I didn’t know a thing about this stall.

Just recently, one of the makan Kakis brought a bag of their Vadais to the table at the basement of Golden Mile Hawker Center where we were eating the Hokkien Mee fried by the old couple.

We were stuffed with old uncle’s wok hei laden Hokkien mee and champion Kopi O and yet that Vadai moved me, spoke to me in Hindi, and made me exclaim :

this is damn Ducking good (cleverly disguised as this is a wholesome blog).

Johorkaki

I went back several times thereafter and tried their other offerings – original big assed prawn, ikan bilis, grego – they were all good.

Makansutra
Makansutra

Their stall started life as a pop-up at pasar malams over the last 30 years.

Run by 30-year-old Stephen Suriyah and his mother Jumana Rani, the stall specialises in Singaporean-style vadai, or Indian prawn fritters.

And it was only in 2019 that they decided to open a stall at Haig Road Food Centres

They were only there for a month but ran into some licensing/tenancy issues and had to give up the space.

Happily, they found a nice stall at the basement of Golden Mile Food Centre and they are there today.

Mr Vadai

Nestled at the ground floor of an industrial building at 116 Changi Road alongside a string of F&B outlets (same stretch with Cafe Mariam which serves great Biryani), there is a little shop called Yeh Yeh Cafe which is home to the delectable Vadais of Mr Vadai.

While waiting for my order, I was lucky enough to speak to a pretty lady at the cashier and I asked her “are you guys connected to The Original Vadai at Golden Mile Center?”

They’re my cousins “ was the reply.

She also told me that like The Original Vadai, Mr Vadai started life participating in pasar malams (night markets).

They opened up at this location 2 years ago.

“And is there a story about the cartoon ? I asked gesturing to the cartoon on the wall.

“That’s my Dad, the founder of Mr Vadai”,

The Ultimate Taste Test

I told my bunch of hard core like minded Makan warriors that we needed to taste all 3 brands of Vadai together in the same laboratory conditions.

So off we went one afternoon to buy Vadais from the 3 stalls.

We departed at about the same time to collect the spoils and congregated at Bar Guan Hin, the delightful home of Sanjay and Kuan, so called because they had an authentic antique Sign board bearing that name in their patio.

At each of the 3 stalls, we bought original prawn Vadais, and also ikan bilis vadai.

The Protagonists

So this is what they look like:

Gina’s Vadai (Dunman Road)

The Original Vadai (Beach Road)

Mr Vadai (Changi Road)

Judgment Day

For the sake of science and the future of humanity, we gorged our faces and produced the following observations:

Cheen & Shufen.

PRAWN

A) Gina’s

Most aromatic. Flat, hence crispier

B) Original Vadai

Tastiest of the lot, really spicy green chilli

IKAN BILIS

A) Gina’s

Like the prawn, it’s flat & crispier. The only one with added nuts

B). Original

A lot of Ikan Bilis, can be overwhelming.

C) Mr Vadai

Tastiest of the lot, aromatic.

Sanjay


Taste – Mr Vadai
Texture (fluffy) – Mr Vadai
Overall – Mr Vadai

Kuan


Taste – Beach Rd
Texture – crispy outside/ fluffy inside – Beach Rd
Overall – Beach Rd.

Yu Li & Chin Yong

Gina’s

Prawn

Drier but crispier
Least tasty
Chewy dough

Ikan Bilis

Dry tasty with ikan bilis , tasty but not visible
Nuts? Not crazy about it


Original Vadai


Prawns

Nice Indian spices taste
Juicy prawn
Soft and fluffy

Ikan Bilis

Tasty ikan bills
No Indian spice
Soft and fluffy

Mr Vadai

Prawn

Slightly sweeter

Ikan Bilis

Tasty
Too little ikan bilis

Favourite stall
1. Original Vadai
2. Mr Vadai

Wolf and Bulldog

Prawn

Favourite was Original Beach Road which edged out Mr Vadai only marginally.

Original was slightly better spiced than Mr Vadai. But both came very close. Both textures were good but could afford to be slightly crispier.

Gina’s was more crispy but the other two were tastier.

Ikan Bilis

Mr Vadai was the clear favourite. It was crustier and very tasty.

There was too much ikan Bilis in Original Vadai and they were not crispy.

Gina’s addition of nuts was weird and the Ikan Bilis could not be tasted.

Overall

Mr Vadai edged out Original Vadai only very marginally because their Ikan Bilis was superior.

Gina’s was no 3.

Chillies

All the Makan Kakis liked the green chillies of Original Vadai and Mr Vadai and felt Gina’s chilli lacked a kick.

Gina’s

Dunman Food Centre

271 Onan Rd, Singapore 424768

Closed on Mondays.
Open Tuesdays to Sundays.
9:30 AM to 3:30 PM

The Original Vadai


Address: 505 Beach Rd, stall #B1-32, Singapore 199583 (Golden Mile Food Centre)
Tel: +65 8588 4181
Hours: 12:00 noon – 7:00pm(Monday closed)

Mr Vadai

Address: Wis@Changi Building, 116 Changi Road, Singapore 419718

Open daily

Tel: +65 8768 2297

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s